Killer Depression
 
I awoke this morning thinking that I would write about something I learned about depression while searching the Internet for information on SAD (Seasonal Affective Disorder, the depression that results from not enough light for those of us who are sensitive to those sorts of things). Then I read Kelly Brewer’s post about the poor Shasta High School student who just committed suicide. I’ve been thinking about this topic a fair amount, actually, ever since David Foster Wallace committed suicide, when the inevitable question of “Why?” comes up. Why would someone so gifted, so successful, so kind, and with such a delightful sense of humor take his own life? Why would a teenager, who has so much to live for, so much promise and potential ahead of him, take his own life?
 
But I can tell you, there is no “why.” There is no reason. You can blame it on this or that—a romantic disappointment, a bankruptcy, a particularly flattening failure or trauma. But basically, what it comes down to is that you are in too much pain to consider living any more. It doesn’t matter that there are millions or maybe even billions of people who are worse off than you, that you might be considered “lucky” in outward terms, that you have a roof over your head, enough to eat, friends, family … None of that matters when you’re in the grip of a crippling depression.
 
It’s true what Kelly says—there is still an incredible stigma attached to depression, despite how many of us are taking antidepressants, how much has been written and studied about it, how enlightened we’re supposed to be as a society about these things. You’d be surprised (or maybe not) how many people expect you to suck it up or just get over it, or who want to plaster some kind of Pollyanna chirpiness over it. Or think that if you just start taking antidepressants, that’ll take care of it.
 
But antidepressants don’t work for everyone (more about this later), not everyone can tolerate the side-effects, and, guess what? An increased risk of suicide is one of the side-effects of most antidepressants. We love to think that we can pop a pill in this day of pharmacological miracles and take care of whatever ails us, but our psyches and minds are just not that simple or straightforward (or well-understood when it comes to emotional or mental illness).
 
Depression is a serious illness. It is potentially fatal. Unfortunately, depressed people can be very difficult to be around, even harder to help. Often certain types of depression express themselves as extreme anxiety, paranoia, anger or substance abuse. I’ve often joked that perhaps depression should be called “Asshole Personality Disorder.” And yet, no matter how irritating or maddening someone suffering from depression might be, it doesn’t help to get mad at them. For someone in the depths of a major depression, it’s all too easy, especially for a teenager, to go from there to “my friends/family/loved ones/the world would be better off without me.”
 
For most of us, it’s a lifelong struggle that starts somewhere in adolescence. Those of us who suffer from it have a genetic predisposition for it, a predisposition that can be triggered by physical, emotional, or verbal abuse, by trauma, or by unrelieved stress. Sometimes you think, why bother to try to get better? I’m just going to get clobbered by it again sometime, no matter how well I seem to be doing at other times. It’s … well, depressing to consider.
 
And yet. Those of us who struggle with serious depression have other people to consider besides ourselves. There are devastated loved ones left behind from a suicide, wrecked families, terrible suffering, agonizing self-recrimination. That alone is enough for most of us to grit our teeth and slog through. But yes, we have ourselves to consider, too. Because, just as surely as we can expect depression to return, we can expect better days, too. And there are things we can do to cope, to lessen or shorten our episodes, and to have longer periods of time between episodes.
 
The most effective treatment I’ve discovered (and this is backed up by numerous studies) is to get regular aerobic exercise, whether it’s running, biking, skating, spinning, dancing, whatever. Meditation is also extremely helpful. Focusing in the present to an almost obsessive degree can help as well; people in the throes of depression often have a difficult time not obsessing over failures and mistakes they’ve made in the past and projecting glum or disastrous scenarios into the future. When I say focus in the present, I mean, focus with laser-like intensity on whatever mundane task you might be engaged in—washing dishes, going for a walk, chopping wood … It doesn’t matter. Just get your brain out of that vicious, deadening cycle. If you have creative abilities—and many creative types suffer from depression—be sure to give yourself some outlet to express them. Cognitive therapy may help some people, too. For SAD sufferers, light box therapy can help, but be aware that there is a possibility that some light boxes can exacerbate an innate propensity for macular degeneration. Do some research before buying.
 
And there is medication. For some people, this is absolutely necessary. Be forewarned, though, about the side-effect I mentioned above, an increased risk of suicide, and the fact that you may not ever be able to stop taking them. Most antidepressants have severe rebound effects. And they can have other serious side-effects as well. In addition, for some people, they stop working.
 
A psychiatrist in Corvallis, Oregon, Jim Phelps, M.D., has an interesting theory about this last phenomenon (my original inspiration for today’s post). He believes that many people who have been diagnosed as having unipolar depression are actually suffering from what he calls “soft bipolar disorder.” If your depression carries with it one or more of the aspects I mentioned above—anxiety, paranoia, anger, etc.—you may suffer from soft bipolar disorder (most people associate grandiosity and extreme hyperactivity with bipolar disorders and those aspects tend to be missing in these cases). If this is true, antidepressants may work for a while for you, then poop out. And if this is true, you may need to be on a mood stabilizer in addition to or instead of an antidepressant. If interested, check out Phelps’ site for more information. His ideas are not widely accepted at this point, but his discussion made a lot of light bulbs go on for me. And it might be worth discussing this idea with your health care provider if you are taking antidepressants and not feeling that they are working for you.
 
Finally, for those of us who don’t tolerate pharmaceuticals well, there are herbal approaches to try. St. John’s wort has an excellent track record for mild to moderate depression, and I have recently started taking two herbs that were recommended by an herbalist for mild bipolar tendencies: Rhodiola rosea and Korean or American ginseng. They do seem to help quite a bit, and I have been through the wringer these last two years, on top of my genetic predisposition for depression (both sides of the family, thank you very much).
 
Of course, any time you consider taking any kind of herbal supplement, check with your health care provider, whether it’s your physician or your acupuncturist or whomever. These types of illness are too serious for self-medication (note: alcohol may be the worst form of self-medication for depression and one of the most common). And as we’ve seen with this poor young man here in Shasta County, deeply loved and mourned, and with the gifted and beloved David Foster Wallace, the consequences can be dire.
 
Most of all, don’t give up. No matter how depressed you are at the moment, things will change. Even if you’ve lost your house, or alienated your friends or gotten fired from your job, things can get better. Maybe there’s a better job out there for you, maybe friends who can’t understand and show you compassion aren’t the best friends for you anyway, maybe your house, unbeknownst to you, was filling up with that awful black mold. And you can always get better. Always.
 
 
Wednesday, December 3, 2008